How values work
This site is in beta. Values are estimates, not rules. Trade what feels fair to you.
Every value tries to show what an average player should expect to trade at, not the best deal anyone ever got. Each item's card says where its value came from and when it last changed.
Where values come from
- Community trading talk. Prices people asked, offered and reported in the community Discord's trading channels (July–November 2026) were read and summarised per item. No names or messages are kept or shown. An item only gets a value this way when at least 3 different traders back it, and the middle of the prices is used, so one loud trader, a lowball or a wild ask can't set it.
- Game rules of thumb, marked with an estimate badge:
- Freaky Token prizes start at about 1 Freaky Token, since one token rolls one prize.
- Shop items are worth their coin price in skulls (a skull sells for 46,620 coins, and coins can't be gifted).
- Rare drops follow their drop chance: about 1 HGF at 1/1,000 and 2–3 HGF at 1/5,000.
- Items you get from an NPC trade or by cooking start at what their ingredients are worth, e.g. a Calico Pill costs one Agate.
- Similar items start alike: for example, gems start from what Garnet and Amethyst trade for, a little higher for gems that sell for more.
- Very cheap items (under ¼ Skull) show as Giveaway, because people usually just gift them.
- Food estimates account for stat gains and documented sources, including recipe unlocks, daily harvests, and crop grow times.
- Doggy Ice Sculpture follows the Crystal Skull rate, using the ratio of their Auction House sell prices.
- A sell price alone never sets a value: items with no better reference stay unvalued. Each item shows the reason for its estimate.
- The curator's judgement, for a few items where the chat and real trading disagree. The item's card says so.
Units
Hourglass Fish (HGF) is the base unit. Freaky Tokens, Crystal Skulls and MDDs are converted through it, so every unit stays consistent. Skulls show the everyday rate (cheap items go for about 1 skull). Bulk skull deals from players with huge stacks go much cheaper and don't count.
Ranges and the price chart
Values are ranges because real trades vary. A wide range means less certainty. Each card's chart shows how the estimate has changed over time.
Found a value that looks wrong?
Values get better with your input. Tell the site's curator on the community Discord. Corrections are listed on the item's card.